The following article appeared in The Audio
Critic
Issue No. 16 Spring through Fall 1991;
written by Peter Aczel, Editor & Publisher.
"This is a beautifully engineered, electronically
flawless piece of equipment of limited usefulness. Crossing a
separately amplified subwoofer over to the main speaker would
be one of its more obvious applications; more about that in a
moment. Here's what the lOB can do - and anything it can do, it
really does perfectly.
In each channel, it can select 12 crossover
frequencies, more or less evenly spaced between 70Hz and 4.5kHz,
and activate Butterworth lowpass and highpass filters that have
the selected frequency as their passband edge. The attenuation
slopes of the lowpass and highpass filters are separately adjustable
to 6, 12, or 18dB per octave (1st, 2nd, or 3rd order), and the
highpass filter level as referenced to the fixed lowpass filter
level can be set in 1 dB steps from -5dB to +5dB. And that's not
all, as they say in those special offers on TV. By manipulating
connections on the back panel, you can turn the lOB into a mono
crossover of even greater versatility- would you believe a variable-slope
threeway or a 4th-order Linkwitz-Riley two-way?--but then of course
you'll need two units for a stereo system. There are also professional
versions with balanced inputs and outputs, special Linkwitz-Riley
modules, you name it- hog heaven for the biamp/triamp crowd.
My measurements revealed absolutely no flaws,
errors, or glitches in this complex system; the filter contours
that I checked at random among the available permutations and
combinations were all dead-on; distortion and noise were pretty
nearly unmeasurable on my test bench at all audio frequencies
regardless of the filter settings; in other words, the signal
paths of the device appear to be perfect. (All right, there is
one potential-but easily remediable-problem. Inside the unit,
a 10-ohm resistor between chassis ground and signal ground appeared
to be the cause of a slight but audible hum in the biamped system
of one of my associates. Shorting the ground side of any one of
the output jacks to the chassis killed the hum.)
David Rich, whose various EE degrees also stand
for El Exigente, had only good things to say about the circuit
design, which is implemented with discrete op amps. He praised
the elegant simplicity of various engineering solutions in the
10 B and called designer Chris Russell "a ridiculously good
engineer," by which I think he meant that Chris goes to almost
ridiculous lengths to refine his circuits and minimize distortion,
without allowing the cost-effectiveness of his designs to go down
the drain. That's what good engineering is all about.
As for the limitations of the 1OB, they have
nothing to do with engineering but stem from the basic problems
of crossing over real world drivers, which are very different
from the idealized amplifier loads assumed by a "perfect"
electronic crossover. Realworld drivers are, in effect, lowpass
and highpass filters; only a dedicated crossover, whether passive
or active, can process those filter characteristics in such a
way that the interacting electrical/acoustical poles and zeros
will yield the combined, measurable lowpass and highpass responses
required in a particular design. In other words, a truly good
crossover for a specific speaker system can't be separately bought
off the shelf. The exception to that rule would be a subwoofer
crossed over well below its upper roll-off frequency to a more
or less full-range main speaker system. That way there are no
preexistent poles imposed on the electronic crossover in the vicinity
of the crossover frequency. Bryston has also come to the realization
that this is the best possible use of the l0B and has recently
added a new model, the "10B-sub," to the line, with
all 12 crossover points at lower frequencies (40, 50, 60, 70,
80, 90, 100, 200, 250, 300, 400, and 500 Hz). I think that makes
a lot of sense.
As a subwoofer crossover, the 10B is unquestionably
state-of-the-art and very reasonably priced for such a complex
piece of equipment. I see no point in evaluating it subjectively,
since the perceived sound quality will depend entirely on the
speakers used and on the specific settings of the controls; the
electronic signal path as such is obviously transparent. If your
biamped subwoofer setup requires, let us say, 18 dB per octave
Butterworth filters crossed over at 100Hz for best results, you
can be certain that no better solution exists than the Bryston
10B. And if you then decide that 70Hz would be a better choice,
the changeover will be totally painless. But don't imagine that
you're a crossover designer for 2-way and 3-way speaker systems
just because you own a 10B. There's a little more to it than that.
We invite you to experience the Bryston SST2 Series amplifiers
20 Year Warranty - A Generation of Music
|